Why Smart Content Marketers Stopped Chasing Viral Hits

_{Day 32/100}

Confession: I've wasted THOUSANDS of dollars chasing viral content. And I'm not alone.

When BeReal exploded onto the scene, marketing teams everywhere scrambled to create strategies for it. Six months later? Ghost town. Everyone had moved on to the next shiny object.

Sound familiar?

It's the content marketing equivalent of that friend who's always starting new diets but never sticks with any of them. Always hungry, never satisfied.

The New Platform Trap Is Real AF

The pattern is painfully predictable:

1. New platform emerges

2. Some random brand gets a lucky viral hit

3. Every marketing director panics: "WE NEED A CLUBHOUSE STRATEGY YESTERDAY!"

4. Resources get diverted from channels that were actually working

5. Diminishing returns kick in on the new platform

6. Another platform emerges, restart at step 1

"We wasted eight months and three team members on Clubhouse," a tech CMO told me. "Got exactly zero customers before the platform died."

And we wonder why marketing budgets get cut first.

What The Data Actually Shows (Warning: It's Unsexy)

While marketers were platform-hopping like caffeinated squirrels, companies that doubled down on boring consistency saw actual growth:

• Newsletters with predictable weekly delivery outperformed the "when inspiration strikes" approach

• Blogs that published consistently on core topics converted 40% better than trend-chasers

• Podcasts that maintained their format rather than chasing viral soundbites kept listeners 3x longer

It's almost like showing up regularly actually matters or something.

The Compound Interest of Not Being Stupid

The most successful content marketers treat their strategy like compound interest—small, consistent investments in proven channels that build over time.

Buffer ignored five "next big platforms" over two years and instead obsessed over optimizing their existing blog and email workflows.

The result? Their content-driven conversion rate doubled while competitors were busy making TikTok dances.

What Actually Works (AKA The Boring Stuff That Makes Money)

For content marketers tired of that constant "we're behind!" anxiety, here's the refreshingly simple approach:

1. Commit to a sustainable production cadence on channels you already own Can you actually publish weekly for 2 years? Yes? Good. That's your plan.

2. Serve a specific audience deeply rather than a broad audience shallowly Better to be 3 people's favorite thing than 300 people's "meh" thing.

3. Measure relationship growth, not just reach or viral potential Track reply rates, not view counts. Trust me on this one.

4. Build content that builds on previous content instead of constant one-offs Each piece should make your previous content MORE valuable, not obsolete.

5. Optimize for the second visit, not just the first viral impression What happens AFTER someone finds you is 100x more important than how they found you.

As one veteran content director put it to me over drinks: "The best time to start a TikTok strategy was three years ago. The second best time is when you've maxed out the ROI on your existing channels—which for most companies, is never."

The secret is there is no secret. Just consistency that compounds.

✌️ Tim "Still has 14 ClubHouse Invites" Hanson
CMO @Penfriend.ai

P.S. What's the weirdest platform your company wasted time on? Reply and tell me.. My personal vote is Google+.